You can easily imagine how good this novel is as this is the second best selling novel ever and has sold over 150 million copies worldwide. Lord of the rings is a master piece but you should understand the time when it was written. Lets remember, the original lord of the rings books were written in 1955. Whenever i try the book bores me to death and i end up dropping it after 50 pages of nothing. Lord of the rings has claimed that the retail and streaming giant has been refused permission by the estate to use the bulk of the books plot. You close the book and never want to see the word precious. The story began as a sequel to tolkiens 1937 fantasy novel the hobbit, but eventually developed into a much larger work. Amazons new lord of the rings cannot use much of tolkiens plot. Trying to read the lord of the ring books and i have to. After billions in sales, hours of adventures, and more than a decade of work, peter jacksons doubletrilogy adaptation of author j. Why is the book the lord of the rings considered bad.
How not to write a sequel to lord of the rings new statesman. This can be both a blessing and a curse for fans of tolkien who have already read the lord of the rings and would like to experience something new. Tolkien transformed the fantasy genre forever when he debuted his epic tale the hobbit in 1937, further altering the genres state with his subsequent trilogy the lord of the rings. If you ever watched some of those black and white films from 40s and 50s youd know how slow they can be and how little action they have in the beginning. What are the best audiobook versions of the lord of the. The lord of the rings elijahwood the hobbit martin freeman. The good guys win because so many of them are willing to go beyond. Tolkien even invented an entire language elven for them. I actually read this series before i read lord of the rings which is probably why i can commit what others will. Criticism of lotr tends to be aimed at the structure and prose itself, its deviation from the usage of good english and so forth, as well as just criticism of the story. The lord of the rings was adapted as a trilogy of films 200103, directed by peter. Lord of the rings the two towers behind the scenes duration. From harry potter to a game of thrones via lord of the rings, ign presents the best fantasy novels ever written. All peter jacksons middleearth movies ranked by tomatometer.
I have listened to it several times and he does an excellent job with character voices, especially the hobbits. A good 3045 minutes of nothing before the story finally gets going. The lord of the rings trilogy definitely belongs on any list of classic series. In 2003, it was named britains best novel of all time in the bbcs the big read. The lord of the rings is the most famous modern work of. The story began as a sequel to tolkiens 1937 fantasy novel the hobbit, but eventually developed into a. The books are small, and the covers of the books are firm but bendy, which will be great for taking on the go, and they have a soft, smooth, leathery feel to them. Written in stages between 1937 and 1949, the lord of the rings is one of the bestselling novels ever written, with over 150 million copies sold. But later as you progress it gets better and better. Mckiernans faery series expands tales drawn from andrew langs fairy books, additionally tying the selected tales together with a larger plot.
All of the lord of the rings films are masterpieces and are unparalleled. Hey, im a big fan of lord of the rings but have never read the books not a big reader. With that being said, here are my top 5 reasons why lord of the rings will stand the test of time and continue to be incredibly popular for years to come. Gollum gets to be pretty annoying by the final pages of the lord of the rings. In 2015, the bbc ranked the lord of the rings 26th on its list of the 100 greatest. Actually, the lord of the rings is one book published in 3 volumes. Graphic novel of lord of the rings good news, bad news 1 april 20 the good news is that later this year, the first in a series of graphic novels based on j.
Three fantasy novels that would make better tv than lord. Peter jackson s adaptations of jrr tolkien s classic lord of the rings novels still come in the short list of great movie adaptations of books. The lord of the rings books were the first major works in the fantasy genre. The prequel, of necessity, resembles the lord of the rings. The movies did a good job of portraying things but they didnt get everything, so read the book. I dont ever remember him reading to me, though i read both the hobbit and the lord of the rings when i was quite young. In my opinion the title of best fantasy ever can only belong to terry pratchetts. The reasons we still read the lord of the rings are countlessthere are as many reasons as there are readers.
Tolkiens lord of the rings lotr series will be coming out. Tolkien himself wrote that if there is a failing in modern films, i. In my opinion the title of best fantasy ever can only belong to terry pratchetts discworld. Its very good, and theres a lot to look forward to since it is the climax. Lotr and the hobbit cannot be considered to be a series because. In 1977, mckiernan, now a moderately successful fantasy author in his own. This past thanksgiving, to prepare for the upcoming release of the hobbit.
Today we are going to take a look at what makes author j. I wonder how many authors set out to write trilogies. As creator of the hobbit, middleearth and the lord of the rings, jrr tolkien is one of the most successful authors in history. Granted, im only 16, but i have read a lot of books.
I really loved the lord of the rings films and was excited to. Ive read the hobbit twice and afterwards i always want to get into the lord of the rings. Is the lord of the rings the best trilogy ever made. Why the fellowship of the ring is the greatest fantasy film ever made brought to you by. The fellowship of the ring is genius, and heres why youtube.
I actually read this series before i read lord of the rings which is probably why i can commit what others will consider. Tolkeins lord of the rings trilogy is one of the bestwritten, imaginative, epic tales of adventure, loyalty, friendship, magic, and good vs. Book aragorn has already made peace with his role as king and isildurs heir decades before meeting frodo, unlike in the movie where he wrestles with that throughout the war of the ring. The iron tower includes the first three novels set in the world of mithgar. The fellowship of the ring why its the best youtube. Tolkiens books are really the hobbits tales, with everyone else along for the ride. As it did for many readers, the lord of the rings and its prequel, the. Its a great, epic story, full of adventure and hope and courage. Tolkien have served as the inspiration to painters, musicians, filmmakers. The adventures of tom bombadil the road goes ever on. Why are tolkiens books so well loved and respected. Tolkiens classic lord of the rings and hobbit books is finally concluded, and now that critics have weighed in on all six films, its time to look back and see how the hobbit. A new lord of the rings book is out this year polygon.
The box they come in is the same soft, leather type feeling and very sturdy. So if you love good fantasy books about magic and wizardry, the harry potter series is one of the best fantasy series of alltime. Theres a good wiki page on it which ill reproduce here. I would, however like to buy and read the lord of the rings but all the editions got me confused, so far i think ive got it narrowed down to a few. The iron tower includes the first three novels set in the world of mithgar collected in a single volume for the first time. The definitive audiobook version of lord of the rings is the 1990 recorded books production, read by rob inglis. The godfather trilogy has godfather 3 which people dont consider as good as its predecessors and star wars has the empire strikes back which i would say the majority find it the best.
If you are unfamiliar with tolkiens work, we will tell you exactly what you can expect from reading his books. Putting this aside the book is a good read in its own. And with that, thousandpage long fantasy epic the lord of the rings is finally over. Is lord of the rings the best fantasy series in your opinion. The story starts with the main antagonist of the story lord sauron who created a ring with the power to rule the world by ruling over all other rings of different powers. Claire armitstead remembers reading the lord of the rings in lagos visuals. John ronald reuel tolkien the lord of the rings is an epic high fantasy novel written by english author and scholar j. An unexpected journey, i picked up the lord of the rings. Tolkien, for instance, intended the lord of the rings to be the first big ass volume of a twovolume set the second being the equally big ass the silmarillion, as well as the sequel to the hobbit. But, for the sake of argument, lets say that you need to write a paper on this or something. Graphic novel of lord of the rings good news, bad news. Tolkiens epic fantasy the lord of the rings had been voted the greatest book of the 20th century in a readers poll conducted by britains channel 4 and the waterstones bookstore chain.
Though the lord of the rings has spawned harry potter, the eragon books, and any number of other imitations aimed at young adults, tolkiens trilogy was. The battle of the five armies stacks up against its predecessors. Ive read and ive read a lot is invest the reader in the world, so that its peril. Though its easy to get lost somewhere between the shire and mordor, there is indeed more to fantasy fiction than hobbits, lords, and their rings. The fellowship of the ring share book recommendations.
The lord of the rings is an epic highfantasy novel written by english author and scholar j. Some books copy the lord of the rings trilogys overall tone or characters. In the world of serious literature, lowbrow, genre fiction and books for teenagers arent even allowed in the main tent. Three fantasy novels that would make better tv than lord of. All of this is good news for the folks behind amazons upcoming lord of the rings adaptation at least, depending on exactly which parts of the history of. There is a good reason why it is one of the best selling novels ever written and why so many other fantasy authors drew upon the setting and lore when it comes to their own work. Dennis lester mckiernan born april 4, 1932 is an american writer best known for his high.